INSTITUTIONAL REPOSITIONING OF TRADITIONAL THRONE.
By
M K ILYASU
Federal Republic of Nigeria’s 1999 Constitution as amended, particularly Section 7 and the Fourth Schedule, provides the constitutional context for local government administration. However, traditional councils do not enjoy a general, independent constitutional mandate equivalent to elected governments.
Civilizational conflict is, in a certain sense, is the crux of the subject matter. The idea of excluding any group for any reason rests uncomfortably with most Northerners, in large part because of our own collective experiences.
Despite some popular beliefs that Traditional thrones never cares for “Talaka/Commoner”, most Northern intellectuals in a literal or immediate sense sought for reforms as an opportunity to flee from poverty, discrimination, lack of opportunity and freedom to express their beliefs and sometimes from outright persecution.
Historical role of Islam and particularly its relation to our colonial past is important in understanding why wouldn’t the same constitution attach greater values and norms to which the Nigerian state is governed. It can be argued however that our Regional retrogression was not because Islam is the problem, rather, the problem is aided by ideologies that non-Moslems remained susceptible to manipulation by political actors.
There is need to think clearly about the risks posed by the constitutional exclusion of the guardians of traditional institutions which has already had such effects as Nigeria is facing a parlous security situation that threatens her national cohesion. The Moslem North who dedicated much of her adult life to fighting colonialism should not be relegated to background in terms constitutional development.
Traditional institutions needed reform, accountability and democratisation. However, removing their administrative and judicial powers should not necessarily require diminishing their capacity for mediation, conflict resolution, community mobilisation and social governance.
My historical assessment would distinguish three stages in the erosion of traditional authority brought by the military administration into the country.
From General Yakubu Gowon’s (1967/68) removal of judicial and police powers to
General Murtala Mohammed (1976), removal from formal local government administration and subsequently,
General Olusegun Obasanjo in 1978 who transferred the statutory land administration to state governors. It became a sequence of military reforms and legislation.
A worthwhile policy direction would be to reconsider the traditional council as a constitutionally recognised institution of community governance, without restoring the features of the old Native Authority system.
One important feature on how the institution acquire legitimacy, adapt and survive within changing political environments can be sourced from the work of Roger Blench on “Traditional Leaders in Nigeria: Main Text of Final Report (2006)”. It provides a useful historical account of the transformation of traditional institutions.
Waziri Ida opined of reinventing traditional institutions as instruments of democratic governance
I believe the debate should move beyond whether traditional rulers deserve constitutional recognition or government allowances.
The more fundamental question is:
Can Religious and moral values, represented by Sokoto and Borno Caliphates coexist as foundations of political civilisation?
A deeper question is whether our contemporary Northern Moslem society relate to Allah and Prophet Muhammad (SAW ) primarily through personal faith and spiritual conviction, or increasingly through religious institutions, clerical authority and political interpretations of Islam?
That distinction could provide the foundation for a substantial debate and examination of the relationship between religion, authority and political behaviour in our existing Moslem societies.
Another question to ask Is whether our democracy primarily is a cultural inheritance or a political project?
We must also take into consideration that Nigeria’s political and social experience involves the interaction of three important foundations:
Christianity and
Indigenous philosophical and customary traditions.
So also the modern constitutionalism, democratic institutions and the rule of law.
How can Nigeria transform its traditional institutions from largely ceremonial and culturally oriented establishments into effective instruments of participatory democracy, grassroots development, national integration and conflict prevention as was the case before the military reforms?
If traditional institutions have come to be viewed as antagonists of modern democracy, then how best can they be properly regulated so that they can complement representative democracy through what might be described as indigenous participatory governance.
The experience of traditional rulers in conflict management, including programmes in Adamawa, Borno and Yobe, demonstrated the practical value of strengthening their institutional capacity. These traditional institutions provide a rich framework to explain and justify actions in a conflict; an identity around which to mobilize people; as an institution with access to material and human resources and a source of inner strength.
To what extent has the exclusion of traditional rulers from formal governance structures affected grassroots governance and security?
How can traditional authority be reconciled with constitutional democracy without creating competing centres of political power?
What institutional safeguards would ensure the sustainability, accountability and political neutrality of traditional authorities?
Nigeria’s 1999 Constitution, particularly Section 7 and the Fourth Schedule, provides the constitutional context for local government administration. However, traditional councils do not enjoy a general, independent constitutional mandate equivalent to elected governments.
Consequently, any proposed repositioning must distinguish between constitutional authority, statutory recognition and customary legitimacy.
The future of traditional institutions in Nigeria should not be determined by nostalgia for their pre-colonial or pre-military administrative powers, but by their capacity to acquire new institutional relevance within a constitutional democratic order.
In other words, the objective should not necessarily be to restore the traditional institution to what it was, but to reconstruct it into what contemporary Nigeria needs it to become.
My conclusion therefore is that Nigeria should reinvent traditional institutions as another tier. It should create a constitutionally recognised system of traditional institutions that complements the three tiers of government, strengthens grassroots democracy and provides a bridge between the historical legitimacy of traditional authority and the existing governance structures.
Mallam M K Ilyasu, a retired Diplomat writes from Kaduna Nigeria, November 20th, 2026


