GRAND DEBATE ON THE ISLAMIC RENEWAL: Re: Killing of Sheikh Yahaya Masussuka. By M K ILYASU

Herald24/7
by
Herald24/7
For the continued free access to our truly qualitative and investigative journalism, we appeal to you to consider making a modest donation of ₦2,000 or more...
- Ebony Magazine Writer
338 Views
13 Min Read
by
Herald24/7
For the continued free access to our truly qualitative and investigative journalism, we appeal to you to consider making a modest donation of ₦2,000 or more...
- Writer
338 Views
13 Min Read

GRAND DEBATE ON THE ISLAMIC RENEWAL:
Re: Killing of Sheikh Yahaya Masussuka.

By

M K ILYASU

Who is Fixing Islam?

In the wake of violence and killings, including that of Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka in front of his residence in Dutsin-ma, in Katsina state last week, together with his assistant, we need to examine what are the obstacles to and opportunities for creating new avenue for engagement and cooperation amongst Moslem clerics of various sects.

Are barriers and openings rooted in a long enduring cultural and religious divide that assassinations remain the only available option to debate?

What makes Sheikh Yahaya Masussuka’s dialectics repugnant to good conscience?

The main contours of this debate are complex, multi faceted and often contentious with camps made up of the different Islamic renewalists and the institutional reformists like Izala, Salafis, Ansaru, etc.

I would draw attention to three characteristics that defined Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka to me.

A. Intellectual breadth.

He does not restrict himself to conventional Qur’anic and Hadith discussions. His interpretations demonstrated an interest in Qur’anic understanding, Islamic intellectual history, mysticism and religious philosophy.

B. Openness to intellectual engagement

His belonging to the broader Sunni community enabled him to engage in scholarly activities that challenged other religious scholars notwithstanding differences in their religious and political orientations.

C. Independent interpretation.

He was particularly willing to advance original interpretations of Qur’anic passages and refer to the earlier followers of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) traditional teachings rather than simply reproduce established explanations.

For example, in discussing the traditional account of Buhari and Muslim, he was drawn to various inconsistencies of time lines and the chains in reporting that never on good sense and judgement could be attributed to the Prophet or his immediate companions.

Having examined reports about Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka, I can identify a more fundamental distinction.
1. Masussuka and established Islamic movements.

His position appears closest to the Qur’aniyyun (Qur’an-centred or Qur’anist approach), although it is important not to assume that every Qur’anist holds identical beliefs.

The distinction is therefore not simply that Masussuka belonged to another religious order. It concerns the sources of religious authority themselves.

2. What made his position particularly distinctive?
Three things stand out:

First, his treatment of Hadith. He questioned the authenticity and authority of certain Hadith traditions, particularly those he considered inconsistent with the Qur’an or the character of Prophet Muhammad.

Second, his method of interpretation. He reportedly employed Tafseerul Qur’ani bil Qur’an—interpreting one passage of the Qur’an through another passage.

Third, his social outlook. Reports describe him as an advocate of peaceful coexistence between Muslims and Christians. He established Qur’an TV/Radio and Masussuka International School in Dutsin-Ma.

The deeper theological question raised by Masussuka’s teachings is whether the Qur’an can be understood and practised independently of the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad? This is where his position I think fundamentally conflicts with mainstream Sunni scholarship.

I think Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka deserves attention as an example of a contemporary religious intellectual who combines traditional religious scholarship with independent inquiry. One particularly interesting aspect of his work is the possibility of examining how religious traditions accommodate intellectual disagreements without necessarily abandoning their foundational beliefs.

Sheikh Masussuka’s case raises an important issue of the difference between religious identity, religious authority and religious conformity.
A person can identify as Muslim, accept the Qur’an and challenge established interpretations without necessarily accepting the authority structures of the dominant religious organisations.
But the question is whether disagreement with such a person justifies intimidation, violence or death by assassins?

I would be particularly interested in exploring one further dimension as to whether Masussuka represents a new form of Islamic reformism in Northern Nigeria, rather than merely another breakaway religious sect.

Sheikh Masussuka and the possibility of a new Islamic reform movement in Northern Nigeria?

This moves the discussion beyond Sheikh Masussuka as an individual religious figure and examines what his teachings might represent for the future of Islamic thought in Northern Nigeria.

It should be examined as a possible expression of Qur’an-centred Islamic reformism, rather than automatically classified as the leader of another breakaway Islamic sect.

The Qur’an-centred reformism that Masussuka was advocating
significantly featured his teaching that the Qur’an should be the ultimate authority in determining Islamic belief and practice, without treating Hadith as an independent binding source of religious law. This places him within the broader intellectual tradition known as Qur’aniyyun, or Qur’anists.

Consequently, his position should not be confused with Izala or Salafism. Although all may criticise aspects of inherited religious practice, they differ fundamentally over the authority of Hadith. A particularly relevant academic contribution is Dr Murtala Uba Mohammed’s paper, Scripture, Science & Sense: A Neo-Quranist’s Discourse in Northern Nigeria.

Mainstream Sunni scholars maintain that the Sunnah is indispensable to understanding and implementing the Qur’an. They point out, for example, that the Qur’an commands Muslims to pray, but the Prophet’s Sunnah provides the practical details of how to perform the prayers.

Masussuka’s reported position challenged the inherited religious authority in
Northern Nigerian where Islam has historically relied on established structures of religious scholarship, including the Maliki jurisprudential tradition, Sufi brotherhoods and later reformist organisations such as Izala. This raises a fundamental question as to who has the authority to determine what constitutes authentic Islam: Was it the established religious institutions, the accumulated scholarship of earlier generations, or the individual believer engaging directly with scripture?

If Hadith is not accepted as an independent source of religious authority, what becomes of centuries of Islamic jurisprudence, theological interpretation and religious instruction?
This is a substantial challenge to the traditional architecture of Islamic scholarship.

This takes us to the Individualization of religious authority.
One possible consequence is that believers become less dependent on established religious institutions and more inclined to examine scriptural texts themselves.
This is consistent with a broader pattern of religious individualisation identified in academic studies of Northern Nigerian Islam. Abdul Raufu Mustapha and Mukhtar U. Bunza, for example, examine the fragmentation of Muslim identities and competition among religious authorities in Northern Nigeria.

The important observation is that earlier reform movements in Northern Nigeria generally sought to reform Muslim society within an established framework of Qur’an, Sunnah and Islamic jurisprudence.
Masussuka’s reported approach questioned an important component of that framework itself; the binding authority of Hadith. He used modern communication like the social media and Qur’an TV/Radio to disseminate his teachings. This is significant because religious authority is no longer exclusively dependent on traditional mosques, established Islamic schools or recognised scholarly networks. Digital communication allows an individual preacher to reach audiences beyond his immediate geographical community. It identifies the emergence of a new Qur’an-centred intellectual tendency in Northern Nigeria.

Research on Islamic digital practices in Northern Nigeria has documented this changing relationship between religious authority and communication technology.

Masussuka’s experience demonstrated that religious disagreement does not occur only between Muslims and non Moslems . There are also profound disagreements within Islam over Scripture, Authority and Interpretation. His case raises questions about who determines acceptable religious doctrine and how disagreements between religious scholars should be resolved.

The reported intervention of the Katsina State Government and its proposed committee of Islamic scholars in November 2025 illustrates how theological disagreements can become matters of public administration and security.

I have the following questions;

1. Was Masussuka actually building a movement?
2. How can religious knowledge be transmitted, authenticated and interpreted.
3. Was his message a recognizable body of teachings that can be studied, debated and transmitted.
4. Does his teachings constitute Islamic reformism rather than ordinary sectarianism or disagreement between scholars?
5. Is there any evidence that his ideas are changing religious attitudes and practices beyond the immediate followers?
6. Will his teachings increase religious pluralism in Islam in Nigeria?
7. Will there be restrictions on freedom of religious inquiry. It must be NOTED that “A society that accommodates religious diversity must also recognise the right of individuals to question established interpretations peacefully”.

Concluding thoughts

The emergence of Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka represents a potentially significant development in the evolution of Islamic thought in Northern Nigeria. His Qur’an-centred approach challenges established conventions of religious authority, particularly the relationship between the Qur’an, Hadith and inherited jurisprudential traditions.

Sheikh Masussuka challenged certain theological positions attributed to some islamic groups. These criticisms must be understood in their textual and historical contexts rather than interpreted as a blanket judgement on every Qur’anist. The Qur’an provides a framework for engagement. It establishes a principle of respectful engagement which provides a useful foundation for examining the relationship between differences, political coexistence and shared social obligations.

All the existing Sunni sects accept the oneness of God; Divine revelation; Prophethood;
Moral accountability: Divine judgement and the importance of Sharia law.

An important development in modern scholarship is the growing recognition that early Islamic historical accounts must be examined critically. Many accounts were written down or transmitted in later generations. Historians therefore compare the Qur’an, early Islamic biographies, hadith literature, documentary evidence and archaeological discoveries. This does not suggest that Sheikh Masussuka was a heretic or apostate.

One aspect that deserves greater attention is that Sheikh Masussuka dialectics was not confined to his understanding alone. Our revered Sheikh Mahmoud Gumi was also not comfortable with Hadith that mocked the household of the Prophet.

My next question therefore is whether Darika, Izala, Salafis, Shi’a, Ansaru are primarily a religious challenge to Islam, or are they also a civilisational challenge to the existing Islamic religious and political establishments in Nigeria?

A civilisational explanation would examine how Islam inherited, reinterpreted and transformed elements of the religious and intellectual environment within which it emerged. It also opens up an interesting comparative question on how did Islamic sectarian relationships differ from its relationship with Christianity?

A purely theological explanation would concentrate on disagreements concerning prophethood, revelation and scripture which very Moslem irrespective of his sectarian leanings agrees: thus, “There is no god but Allah and Prophet Muhammad is his servant and messenger. Qur’an is the last testament”.

2nd November 2026

Share This Article
For the continued free access to our truly qualitative and investigative journalism, we appeal to you to consider making a modest donation of ₦2,000 or more to support this noble endeavour. By contributing to Ebony Herald International, you are helping to sustain a relevant, credible and independent press, while ensuring that our journalism remains free and accessible to all. Account Details: Account Name: Ebony Herald Publishers Bank: Union Bank Plc Account Number: 0038227281 You can also subscribe to our monthly magazine for ₦7,000 per month, with delivery/shipment inclusive. For advert placement, please call: 08162341445 Email: ebonyherald@rocketmail.com WhatsApp: +234 816 234 1445
Leave a Comment

Ads